{% extends "base.html" %} {% set active_page = "ratings" %} {% block title %}Ratings — IETF Draft Analyzer{% endblock %} {% block extra_head %}{% endblock %} {% block content %}

Rating Analytics

Distribution and analysis of AI-generated ratings across five dimensions. Each draft is rated 1–5 on novelty, maturity, overlap, momentum, and relevance by Claude AI, then combined into a weighted composite score.

Composite Score Distribution

The composite score is a weighted average of all five dimensions (each 20%). Scores range from 1.0 (low) to 5.0 (high). Most drafts cluster in the 2.0–3.5 range.

Score Distributions by Dimension

Novelty: originality of ideas. Maturity: completeness and specification detail. Overlap: redundancy with other drafts (high = more unique). Momentum: adoption likelihood and community traction. Relevance: importance to AI agent infrastructure.

Category Rating Profiles

Novelty vs Maturity (bubble = relevance)

Each dot is a rated draft. Drafts in the top-right corner are both novel and mature — prime candidates for standardization. Bubble size reflects relevance. Click a point to view the draft.

Top 20 Drafts by Composite Score

Highest-rated drafts across all dimensions. Green (4+) = strong, amber (3) = moderate, grey (<3) = needs improvement.

# Draft Score Novelty Maturity Relevance Momentum Overlap Category
{% endblock %} {% block extra_scripts %} {% endblock %}